Lots of legal information, but in small doses

Latent defects: the burden of proving hidden defects

Categories:

Real estate and construction, Civil and commercial litigation

Although we most often hear about latent defects when purchasing a new home or property, it should be noted that the legal warranty (or warranty against latent defects) provided in the Civil Code of Quebec, is not limited to real estate but can be applied to any sale.

That said, it should be noted that in cases involving hidden (or latent) defects, the details surrounding the burden (or onus) of proof are of particular interest. In fact, while the burden of proving the existence of a defect falls on the Plaintiff, it is up to the Defendant (once the existence has been established) to prove that the defect should have been discovered by the Plaintiff. In other words, it is up to the Defendant to demonstrate that the defect in question should have been noticed by the buyer, thus meaning that it was an apparent defect and therefore not covered by the legal warranty.

In a recent judgment, the Court of Appeal confirmed this point after the trial judge ordered the Defendant (Appellant on the merits) to pay the Respondent (Plaintiff on the merits) several million dollars because of defective glue products that were sold.

Indeed, the Court unanimously concluded that the appeal was unfounded and that the trial judge properly applied the law. The Court pointed out that once the existence of the defect is established, it is the Defendant who bears the burden of proving that the defect should have been discovered by the Plaintiff.

Although this all may seem somewhat technical, it is incredibly important to account for all these technicalities when preparing a lawsuit, in order to avoid getting caught at the end with a judgment ordering you to pay substantial sums of money that you may not necessarily have.

 

Harry Karavitis, Attorney-at-Law

Alepin Gauthier Avocats inc.


Latent defects: the burden of proving hidden defects
Back to the list

Do you like this publication?


Contact us

Contact us

Laval

450 231-1277
3080, boul. Le Carrefour
Bureau 400
Laval Qc Canada H7T 2R5

Lasalle

514 364-3383

Montréal

514 335-3037

Fax

450 681-1476

Directions

Follow us